The Difference Between Gaston And Beast

We watched Beauty and the Beast last night in honor of the 25th anniversary and because we bought a new DVD player. This movie is a part of my childhood. Like baking cookies, swimming in the river, and jumping on the trampoline, I watched Beauty and the Beast with a zealous obsession.

The first time I watched Beauty and the Beast I must have been five or six-years-old. I was enchanted by the music, Belle’s passion for books, and I loved Beast. I knew Gaston was the bad guy, he was the villain. I thought that the moral of the story was to love someone based on who they were on the inside vs. what they looked like on the outside. Gaston was ugly on the inside and beautiful on the outside. Beast was ugly on the outside and beautiful on the inside. (I understand that these are objective statements, but I think we can agree that this was the allegory that Disney was going for when they created these characters.)

Watching the movie as an adult, the enchantment was still there, but it was accompanied by a critical eye. I was disturbed by the scene where Gaston proposes to Belle. Gaston stalked Belle across her living room and she made a point to keep furniture between the two of them. He pinned her against the front door and she squirms away to avoid his kiss. She was at his mercy. She was his prisoner.

While watching that scene as an adult, I realized that even my six-year-old self empathized with Belle. This scene made me uncomfortable as a young girl. I felt Belle’s fear and vulnerability in that moment.

gaston

gastonproposed

tumblr_miwccwcnac1qgcra2o1_500

I then scrutinized Beast’s behavior and I thought why is he any better? Why did I not fear Beast the same way I feared Gaston? I had every reason to dislike him as much as I did Gaston. Beast imprisons kind, little old Maurice. He then keeps Belle prisoner. He shouts at her and bosses her around.

beauty-and-the-beast-3

Beast and Gaston were both really quite awful. They both wanted Belle for different selfish reasons. Gaston wanted a beautiful breeder wife. Beast wanted to use her to break the spell. Beast was Gaston and Gaston was Beast.

My interpretation and the moral of Beauty and the Beast just went up in flames. The foundation of my childhood just crumbled. Both “men” were ugly.

Well, we all know that Beast softens. He protected her from the wolves, gave her the most envy-inducing library, and he waltzed her around a stunning ballroom, but don’t forget that she was still his prisoner while all of this took place. (Belle may have showed signs of Stockholm syndrome when she didn’t jump on Phillip and ride away after the Beast was down after the wolf fight.)

Beast was Gaston before the spell was cast. He was Gaston when he turned the witch away who was disguised as a poor beggar woman. He was Gaston while he kept Belle prisoner. He thought the world owed him everything.

So what is the difference between Gaston and Beast? What is the actual moral of the story? REDEMPTION.

The major shift towards Beast’s redemption happened when he set Belle free and  sacrificed the chance to break the spell and regain his former life.

The second major act that showed his character change was the fight scene between Gaston and Beast. The fight was really an allegory to Beast’s inner struggle. By showing mercy to Gaston, he proved his redemption again. When Gaston falls to his death that same selfish part of Beast died with him. That was when Belle realized her love and the spell was broken.

I would love to hear your thoughts and comments on Beauty and the Beast and what the movie meant to you.

-Rachel McKee

Advertisements

Author: Rachel McKee

Currently writing a YA novel. I love reading about everything, truly I'm not a book snob. Lately I have been "reading" a lot of picture books to my baby boy. In my past life before motherhood, I was a professional technical editor and writer.

7 thoughts on “The Difference Between Gaston And Beast”

  1. It has been awhile since I’ve watched the movie so I don’t know as though I have much to say about it in particular but I will say that it always amazes me how the creators of animated films always manage to imbed some semblance of adult content in movies otherwise aimed at children. Granted, we don’t understand these undertones as kids but it’s always interesting going back to our childhoods and watching these same movies through an adult lens.

    Things that make you go “hmmmm” indeed.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I wasn’t *very* young when the movie came out – but I remembered the original fairytale being much different. For one thing, the fact that Disney thought it was necessary to invent Gaston, to prove that Belle apparently only had the choice between a physically attractive but morally/emotionally heinous arse and a wealthy, enchanted animal-person really destroyed the moral of the Brothers Grimm story, sets the feminist movement back about 100 years. The original moral was that the Beast had been cursed for his immorality, and Beauty’s pure heart refused to give up on him, and she softened him and helped to change his point of view, and then her love ultimately saved the good person that was hidden inside the Beast. That, to me, made a much more powerful statement than the movie – although they kept most of the element of Belle was a nice, warm-hearted person who taught the Beast a lot in that area – but getting rid of the two sisters who didn’t want to be the Beast’s prisoner (brush up on your Grimm, Disney!) really removed the real reason that we would’ve seen Beauty’s good heart in the midst of selfishness and a wayward moral compass. I would’ve been much more impressed with that.

    Since after The Lion King and The Little Mermaid (and both of those had some questionable elements as well), Disney films have, as a whole, really gone downhill – with the exception of most of the Pixar movies.

    If you compare the Disney classics – Snow White, Cinderella, Mary Poppins, The Aristocats – you get a much different idea of the type of entertainment Walt was after. I don’t know if he’d be impressed with what has become of his company nowadays.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Great thoughts! I never watched Beauty and the Beast when I was younger. I was afraid of the Beast!

    I was probably 18 before I actually watched the movie and, for many of the reasons you have pointed out, I wasn’t too impressed with the Beast. I didn’t think as deeply as you did, however; I love the idea of the final battle between the Beast and Gaston being an allegory for the Beast’s inner struggle. Brilliant analysis!

    Liked by 1 person

Comments

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s